Buried cost concerns haunt the 3D IC
By Chris Edwards | June 13, 2011
Interest is building around the idea of the 3D integrated circuit (IC). It can potentially squeeze entire sensors into one tiny plastic package and deliver tiny computers with massive amounts of high-speed memory. But, in a sense, the industry has been here before. Back in the early 1990s, multichip modules as they were known before they got the 3D rebranding were seen as a to deal with the growing problems of designing dense integrated circuits (ICs).
Unfortunately, the technology was expensive to implement, relegating to specialised applications except for the situation where Intel, in order to keep up with its performance targets for PCs, adopted them for some of its Pentium processors.
Manufacturers also found that, outside of some specialised RF applications where it made sense to put components directly onto a ceramic substrate, memory was the only thing you could expect to put in a multichip module and expect it to work. The industry developed screening procedures to make it easier to weed out duds before they were integrated into a module where they could be fully tested. Realistically, only memory was predictable enough to be supplied in the form of known good die.
Where possible, Intel and others always stepped back to monolithic silicon. The arrival of the mobile phone changed the situation for 3D ICs as advances in wirebonding, wafer thinning and handling made it cost effective to combine different forms of memory in one package and save board space.
The increasing cost of developing SoCs is making companies outside the memory business look seriously at 3D ICs to stack other ICs than memory – and use much closer coupling between the individual chips to provide a performance boost. At first sight, it looks to be a good thing for mixed-signal design.
You can kiss goodbye to substrate-borne interference from noisy digital circuits – mostly. You can breathe a sigh of relief from not having to deal with immature process models and limited voltage headroom. And say hello to mature, well-understood processes and, if you need them bags of readymade circuit-level IP. Not only that the wafer cost for the mixed-signal parts can be much lower than that of an advanced process needed for dense digital circuitry.
But the move to 3D is not a one-way bet. Cost remains a significant issue. Even the most optimistic projections for the additional processing cost of putting dice on top of each other using high-speed, low-inductance interconnect is around 15 per cent per die. This could easily wipe out the wafer cost advantage of using cheaper, older processes for mixed-signal sections.
There are also practical issues that will tend to increase overall cost. The issue is less serious for 3D ICs that use a common silicon interposer as techniques similar to flip-chip bonding can be used to take conventional dice and mount them in one package with high-performance interconnect. However, you do have to factor in the cost of the silicon interposer itself, which, to maintain high interconnect density may need a reasonably advanced base process for the metallisation. For example, Xilinx uses a 65nm process for the interposer in its multichip FPGAs.
Faced with this, the through-silicon via (TSV) looks ideal as you can dispense with the largely passive silicon IC underneath and you get to save more board space by stacking devices vertically.
Ideally, you would have the contact on the lowest layer next to the transistors that talk to it – assuming it's not just a through-die connection. Unfortunately, this is hard to make and causes high stresses around devices that don't work well with those kinds of stresses. So, the contacts have to go in at least halfway up the metal stack where the lines are comparatively wide. So, not only do the vias wipe out precious die area, they block the routing as well, which can cause problems for shape-sensitive analogue routing.
Even with via-middle and via-last processes, there are still significant stresses around the large copper-filled via: the silicon is 'pulled' toward the via. This is a problem for digital but it's more serious for analogue circuitry. So the keep out zone around the TSV can be pretty big for active devices. Simulations by IMEC and Synopsys have indicated that it this zone is ten times larger for analogue devices than digital. The simulation work showed that the stress around a single TSV calls for a keep-out zone of around 20µm.

It makes sense to put clusters of TSVs close to each other and simply treat them as an unusable block. But the keepout zone can expand to 150µm or 200µm. This will necessarily limit the density of TSV contacts, perhaps forcing the mixed-signal devices to the top of the stack to limit the number of through connections that affect the die. And it will increase the die size of the mixed-signal part, which might be tolerable in terms of cost given the lower wafer price but still needs to be factored in.
3D certainly looks interesting for mixed-signal SoCs, but the higher cost of designing for monolithic silicon could pay off in better margins for the final product.
Featured Video
Titan: Fastest Path to Mixed Signal Silicon
Mar Hershenson provides an overview of Titan and how it allows analog designers to more fully explore the design space to significantly improve performance and dramatically reduce power consumption on both new and existing analog designs.
Webcast Highlights
SoC Designers, Get a Clear Vision of 20-nm Success
With lithography limits, double patterning, high-k gates, low-k interconnects and myriad new requirements, the path to silicon success at the 20-nm node can look a little fuzzy. You need an advanced, scalable, integrated SoC design environment that delivers fast and predictable timing and layout closure. Attend this webcast to get a clear vision of how Magma's Silicon One technology can get your 20-nm SoC to silicon fast and with better results.





3D integrated circuit (IC) is
3D integrated circuit (IC) is really necessary, they should really come up something new idea for budget. IC could change the entire the history through TSV. The money used in making can be easily recovered.
Raybuck rocker panels
3D integrated circuit sector
3D integrated circuit sector is one sector which expanding very quickly and companies which are moving towards this sector and investing in the IC sector are in profit than other investment.Jim Thompson
Yeah its very effective if we
Yeah its very effective if we use 3D IC. It increases the speed of processing much faster. Website
thanks!
I am very surprised that Intel's Pentium has only been adopted from early 90's technology innovation.
Kollagen|Proactol Plus
3D technology is used at
3D technology is used at massive scale and its use is increasing with time. It is good to use and good quality images can be viewed through this technology. I want to learn about its more usage.
cranbrook pets website review
This interesting post made me
This interesting post made me smile. Maybe if you put in a couple of pics it will make the whole thing more interesting.. mole removal at home
Now the conditions are
Now the conditions are different and technology is much advanced as compared to 1990's. Today's world refer to digital than analog. online career training
nice
Though today its the edge of 3D pictures many people prefer for the 2Ds only as its having much resolution as well as the screen size.wow guild website
Post is nicely written and it
Post is nicely written and it contains many good things for me. I am glad to find your impressive way of writing the post. Now it become easy for me to understand and implement the concept. Thanks for sharing the post
"i7 laptop"
Don't some fire extinguishers
Don't some fire extinguishers use 3D integrated circuits now?
office2010key
Quick buck released today is applicable to iPhone and Android mobile payment products “quick brush”, similar to a external card reader, provide a plug, and have no the function that brush card limit. Microsoft Office 2010 is free for you.
Office 2007
Microsoft Office 2007
Office 2007 Download
Office 2007 Professional
MS Office 2007
Office 2007 Key
buy microsoft office 2007
Download Office 2007
Microsoft Office 2007 Professional
purchase microsoft office 2007
Microsoft Office 2007 Download
Office 2010
Download Office 2010
MS Office 2010
Office 2010 Key
Office 2010 Download
Office 2010 Professional
Microsoft Office 2010 Download
buy microsoft office 2010
Windows 7
Microsoft Windows 7
Win 7
Download Windows 7
Buy Windows 7
Microsoft Office 2011
http://softwarestockss.blogspot.com
http://software-stocks.com
Homuth has a lot of Talent
Homuth has a lot of Talent and he surely will be an top dog in relation to this. The questions asked above are also very nice and he has answered them very brilliantly. Workwear
Very interesting discussion
Very interesting discussion glad that I came across such informative post. Keep up the good work friend. Glad to be part of your net community.
research papers | term papers | essays | dissertations | theses
Thanks for all the careful,
Thanks for all the careful, frame-by-frame analysis of the phoenix dui attorneys with known Pileateds. When you compare the two sets of images it becomes much easier to see that the Luneau woodpecker could be/is definitely a Pileated.
This is a wonderful site
This is a wonderful site where we are getting more information.rabbit vibrator I have been talking with my friend about, he though it is really interesting as well. Keep up with your good work; I would come back to you.
Regards,
I Need An Essay For Me
Nice
Post very nicely written, and it contains useful facts. I am happy to find your distinguished way of writing the post. Now you make it easy for me to understand and implement. Thanks for sharing with us Boligindretning
This post is helpful with an
This post is helpful with an analysis of 3D integrated circuit I am doing for a specific group of people. Do you have any other articles to suggest on this topic? Thanks ecommerce website design
I am happy to find so many
I am happy to find so many useful information about Boat Speed here in the post, a good player can change the situation using these tips, thanks for sharing
"Federal resume writers"
Thanks for all the careful,
Thanks for all the careful, frame-by-frame analysis of the phoenix bankruptcy attorney with known Pileateds. When you compare the two sets of images it becomes much easier to see that the Luneau woodpecker could be/is definitely a Pileated.
Dont infer too much you can't
Dont infer too much you can't compare " I think this is an informative post and it is very useful and knowledgeable."
Regards,
Cordless Tools
We will not be able to admit
We will not be able to admit this in current situation "I have really relished understanding your blog articles."
Regards,
Tool Parts
3D IC
Interesting concept for ITV consumption in the market today. Don't worry about the cost, move it forward.
3D everything
Turning it on to the innovative world. Small Business SEO
Depending on the Times, the
Depending on the Times, the lack of space in the town has reached the point where a handful of burial plots are not sold (Trinity Church Cemetery in Washington Heights and Washington Cemetery with two of them). Calvary, the largest city in the Catholic cemetery is reaching a level quickly... VPN Reviews thanks
I just stumbled upon your
I just stumbled upon your blog and wanted to say that I have really enjoyed reading your blog posts. Any way I'll be subscribing to your feed and I hope you post again soon. css old papers 2008
The programming language's
The programming language's surface form is known as its syntax. Most programming languages are purely textual; they use sequences of text including words, numbers, and punctuation, much like written natural languages. On the other hand, there are some programming languages which are more graphical in nature, using visual relationships between symbols to specify a program. Thanks a lot.
Regards,
Buy Dissertation | Dissertation Dissertation | Dissertation Writing
You made some decent factors
You made some decent factors there. I appeared on the web for the problem and found most people will associate with along with your website.
best memory foam mattress
What a huge disappointment,
What a huge disappointment, nothing fresh here but super cheesy sentimental rubbish, plot gaps so big you could drive a bus through, interstellar aliens that can work out how to defeat a few humans on foot running through the same bit of countryside help with resume
This classic reissue is
This classic reissue is enduring. First, it was known as the nike air max or the Air Max III until it was reissued. It then was resurfaced under the name of nike air max 90 in 2000. The classic sneakers have lots of nice qulities, among which its stunning color combining is specially outstanding. It is the stunning color conbining that makes the shoes populai with people. research paper writers
Howdy! Do you know if they
Howdy! Do you know if they make any plugins to assist with Search Engine Optimization? I'm trying to get my blog to rank for some targeted keywords but I'm not seeing very good gains. If you know of any please share. Thanks!dermatend reviews
They use sequences of text
They use sequences of text including words, numbers, and punctuation, much like written natural iphone best apps languages. On the other hand, there are some programming languages which are more graphical in nature, using visual relationships between symbols to specify a program...thanks
Useful information. semenax
Useful information. semenax Fortunate me I found your website by chance, and I am surprised why this twist of fate didn’t came about earlier! I bookmarked it.
What’s upward my homie read a
What’s upward my homie read a lot of your other articles and wanted to determine if you would be up for swapping site hyperlinks provestra Thanks again for taking the time to put this online.
amazing topic
I like to spend much time in the Internet, but, unfortunately not often find something worthy and interesting to read.
I liked the way you covered the topic and depth with which you explain these important things. thanks
Online Games
I wanted to thank you for
I wanted to thank you for this great read!! I definitely enjoyed every little bit of it, I have you bookmarked to check out all the new stuff you post...
seo florida
Now that was a really healthy
Now that was a really healthy dialogue right there. Gets your blood pumping really fast and strong. Thanks a lot for sharing this with us. pak navy jobs 2012
Your blog provided us with
Your blog provided us with valuable information to work with. Each & every tips of your post are awesome. Thanks a lot for sharing. Keep blogging.
How To Become a cna
Always so interesting to
Always so interesting to visit your site.What a great info, thank you for sharing. this will help me so much in my learning.
I hope you have a nice day!
I hope you have a nice day! Very good article, well written and very thought out. I am looking forward to reading more of your posts in the future personal statement ucas
I'm usually to running a blog
I'm usually to running a blog and i really recognize your content. The article has really peaks my interest. I am going to bookmark your website and keep checking faisalabad jobs
This is my very first time
This is my very first time visiting here. I found numerous helpful stuff in your weblog especially the ongoing dialogue. From the tons of comments on your posts, I suppose I'm not the only person having fun in reading your 32 weeks pregnant website. Carry on the great work.
Microsoft Office 2010 85% off
We realize, WindowsVista began, the device carries a built-in tool called “captured picture of components,” can partially replaced third-party screenshots tools, office 2010 the good news is we could office 2010 directly in complete screenshots operation, can say is much more convenient. Switch the signal from office 2010 Word2010 or Excel 2010 “Insert” TAB, we could maintain “written” functional groups called “found a Screenshot” button, here to compliment multiple screenshots mode, click “Screenshot” button, we are able to be found here current opened a window, click on the screenshots picture after inserting the latest document might be selected.If choose “ScreenClipping”, return can find desktop mouse cursor had become a fine cross, press the mouse left key can intercept corresponding picture, loosen the mouse can return to document window, just intercepted images may be automatically entered into the latest document. Whether or not this was in office 2010 PowerPoint2010 demo manuscripts window, switch to “Insert” TAB, “Screenshot” button position gone to live in “aptly titled” functional groups, we may also rapid Insert the present window here the thumbnail or intercept window.office 2010 Skills 2: eliminate the background picture Already insert Word document to the pictures, you can easily get rid of the background picture, so that they don’t could do with huge PhotoShop, more is much better still can also add or remove the watermark. Choose photos, plunge to “PictureTools TAB, called” is found here BackgroundRemoval “button and then click on” BackgroundRemoval “button, you’ll soon put would like to mark out the photographs, whether very magical?Skills 3: custom graphical user interface office 2010 Professional Plus gui may, based on the needs in our own definition, operation is quite simple. Click on the icon inside upper left corner Office button enter configuration panel, click “CustomRibbon”, here to all or any tabs, button customized for example can adjust each TAB position, delete option card, may will originally displayed in English for your Chinese, the object changes as selected
links
well, this is really a nice post.I really like the way you start and conclude your thoughts. Thank you so much for this information. keep posting such good stuff. href="http://www.google.html">zobi //
Hello,I love reading through
Hello,I love reading through your blog, I wanted to leave a little comment to support you and wish you a good continuation. Wishing you the best of luck for all your blogging efforts. http://www.ip-adress.com/proxy_list/
well, this is really a nice
well, this is really a nice post.I really like the way you start and conclude your thoughts. Thank you so much for this information. keep posting such good stuff. Dissertation writing service
gerat blog
I was reading a lot about link building; nevertheless, I still do not realize a correct way to make my web traffic optimization work well! I tried to make something with that, but, I was not able to get a good way to fix it! Finally, I found the forum posting services I could rely on! I am completely fulfilled at this time!Shop Vac Acesssories
It is very reasonable for
It is very reasonable for global corporations to invest in new technologies. But talking about 3D, you can not be sure. It's more like new fashion, nothing more. And statistics about freelance writing job prove it
By visiting your websites i
By visiting your websites i am glad to say that its a very useful website and posts are owsum thanx for sharing such a useful posts..! fighting games
qiyyvgwq
eyvvjqg
Expences
People have already to make a lot of expenses. It would be great if they would be exempt from certain charges. Tagesgeldzinsen vergleichen
Post new comment